You probably heard it already: Linux.conf.au is live streaming its video in a Microsoft proprietary format.
Fortunately, there is now a re-broadcast that you can get in an open format from http://stream.v2v.cc:8000/ . It comes from a server in Europe, but relies on transcoding here in New Zealand, so it may not be completely reliable.
UPDATE: A second server is now also available from the US at http://repeater.xiph.org:8000/.
Today, the down under open source / Linux conference linux.conf.au in Wellington started with the announcement that every talk and mini-conf will be live streamed to the Internet and later published online. That’s an awesome achievement!
However, minutes after the announcement, I was very disappointed to find out that the streams are actually provided in a proprietary format and through a proprietary streaming protocol: a Microsoft streaming service that provides Windows media streams.
Why stream an open source conference in a proprietary format with proprietary software? If we cannot use our own technologies for our own conferences, how will we get the rest of the world to use them?
I must say, I am personally embarrassed, because I was part of several audio/video teams of previous LCAs that have managed to record and stream content in open formats and with open media software. I would have helped get this going, but wasn’t aware of the situation.
I am also the main organiser of the FOMS Workshop (Foundations of Open Media Software) that ran the week before LCA and brought some of the core programmers in open media software into Wellington, most of which are also attending LCA. We have the brains here and should be able to get this going.
Fortunately, the published content will be made available in Ogg Theora/Vorbis. So, it’s only the publicly available stream that I am concerned about.
Speaking with the organisers, I can somewhat understand how this came to be. They took the “easy” way of delegating the video work to an external company. Even though this company is an expert in open source and networking, their media streaming customers are all using Flash or Windows media software, which are current de-facto standards and provide extra features such as DRM. It seems apart from linux.conf.au there were no requests on them for streaming Ogg Theora/Vorbis yet. Their existing infrastructure includes CDN distribution and CDN providers certainly typically don’t provide Ogg Theora/Vorbis support or Icecast streaming.
So, this is actually a problem founded in setting up streaming through a professional service rather than through the community. The way in which this was set up at other events was to get together a group of volunteers that provided streaming reflectors for free. In this way, a community-created CDN is built that can deal with the streams. That there are no professional CDN providers available yet that provide Icecast support is a sign that there is a gap in the market.
But phear not – a few of the FOMS folk got together to fix the situation.
It involved setting up Icecast streams for each room’s video stream. Since there is no access to the raw video stream, there is a need to transcode the video from proprietary codecs to the open Ogg Theora/Vorbis format.
To do this legally, a purchase of the codec libraries from Fluendo was necessary, which cost a whopping EURO 28 and covers all the necessary patent licenses. The glue to get the videos from mms to icecast streams is a GStreamer pipeline which I leave others to talk about.
Now, we have all the streams from the conference available as Ogg Theora/Video streams, we can also publish them in HTML5 video elements. Check out this Web page which has all the video streams together on a single page. Note that the connections may be a bit dodgy and some drop-outs may occur.
Further, let me recommend the Multimedia Miniconf at linux.conf.au, which will take place tomorrow, Tuesday 19th January. The Miniconf has decided to add a talk about “How to stream you conference with open codecs” to help educate any potential future conference organisers and point out the software that helps solve these issues.
UPDATE: I should have stated that I didn’t actually do any of the technical work: it was all done by Ralph Giles, Jan Gerber, and Jan Schmidt.
9 thoughts on “Video Streaming from Linux.conf.au”
Thanks Silvia. I complained about this in my blog post yesterday.
“Just get Windows users to use VLC and stream like normal people (it is even mentioned in the Windows section). Silverlight is heavily patented, smothered in Novell-Microsoft deals and a blight on free software. It only advances Microsoft
Unfortunately ogg/theora does not have a reputation as a very high quality codec, although maybe this has improved recently. Can video from xvid be streamed? but xvid encoding is stuffed over by patents I suppose. It’s good that the ogg/theora patent-free algorithms exist anyway.
@Sam – have you looked at recent comparisons of codec quality? See for example http://people.xiph.org/~greg/video/ytcompare/comparison.html . Theora has improved in quality hugely since last year, so you may want to give it another go.
xvid codecs are non-free, too, and we would need to pay a license fee for those, too, so, no: we really want to continue supporting only open and free codecs.
Thanks silvia, yes it seems that Theora is now a lot better than flv (h263), maybe it is not quite as good as h264 but I bet it encodes a lot faster. I can’t use h264 for my work anyway because it takes too long to encode it. I’m impressed, and I’ll try using theora for my own video projects. 🙂
by the way, the xvid codecs are free software, but they are subject to some patents, so I guess it’s dangerous to use them for non-pirate publication purposes without a patent license.
Comments are closed.