In the W3C Media Fragment Working Group (MFWG) we have had long discussions about the use of the URI query (“?”) or the URI fragment (“#”) addressing approach for addressing directly into media fragments, and the diverse new HTTP headers required to serve such URI requests, considering such side conditions as the stripping-off of fragment parameters from a URI by Web browsers, or the existence of caching Web proxies.

As explained earlier, URI queries request (primary) resources, while URI fragments address secondary resources, which have a relationship to their primary resource. So, in the strictest sense of their specifications, to address segments in media resources without losing the context of the primary resource, we can only use URI fragments.

Browser-supported Media Fragment URIs

For this reason, URI fragments are also the way in which my last media fragment addressing demo has been implemented. For example, I would address